Slightly lower-alcohol and higher residual sugar than its immediate siblings, the Barthelmes’ 2009 Gewurztraminer Furstentum Vieilles Vignes otherwise has a lot in common with the corresponding Steingrubler, featuring as it does mint candy, celery root, quince preserves, and brown spices. There is a bit less finishing succulence to this otherwise impressively persistent wine than in that Steingrubler, and I would be inclined to drink this within the next 4-6 years. Although Maurice and Jacky Barthelme continued to pick their 2009 Rieslings into October and achieved satisfyingly ripe flavors, they did so without suffering high alcohol or unbalanced sweetness. Unsurprisingly (whether or not verifiably), they implicate the accumulated experience and effects of a biodynamic regimen in these results. Equally importantly, the levels of acidity in their 2009 Rieslings are ample and efficacious. With Pinot Gris and Gewurztraminer, they were forced to discharge high must weights in the form of almost universally high residual sugar, with attractive if seldom distinguished results. The Mann 2008s are characterized by particularly concentrated and positively efficacious acidity, all of the Rieslings weighing-in at what on paper might look like an excessive 9 grams or more. Not only have the Barthelme brothers been together now for 21 vintages – to me it still seems like yesterday that I “discovered” their 1988s – but they point out that most of their present crew has been together for nearly a decade, which is bound to have been instrumental in their having been able to repeatedly expand into new vineyards without sacrificing the highest standards, not to mention with their enthusiasm still youthful.Importer: Weygandt-Metzler, Unionville, PA; tel. (610) 486-0800

The Mann 2008 Gewurztraminer Furstentum Vieilles Vignes displays moderate sweetness against a background of varietally atypical acidity but with archetypical scents of rose petal, bacon, celery seed, and pea tendrils. Subtly oily in feel; elegant and wafting in its sense of inner-mouth perfume; this develops a pleasing hint of herbal bitterness, peppery piquancy, and pungent grapefruit rind in its finish that help cancel out the influence of 36 grams residual sugar. The contrast with the energy of the corresponding Steingrubler is striking but this long, refined, understated Gewurztraminer deserves to be followed for 15 or more years. Although Maurice and Jacky Barthelme continued to pick their 2009 Rieslings into October and achieved satisfyingly ripe flavors, they did so without suffering high alcohol or unbalanced sweetness. Unsurprisingly (whether or not verifiably), they implicate the accumulated experience and effects of a biodynamic regimen in these results. Equally importantly, the levels of acidity in their 2009 Rieslings are ample and efficacious. With Pinot Gris and Gewurztraminer, they were forced to discharge high must weights in the form of almost universally high residual sugar, with attractive if seldom distinguished results. The Mann 2008s are characterized by particularly concentrated and positively efficacious acidity, all of the Rieslings weighing-in at what on paper might look like an excessive 9 grams or more. Not only have the Barthelme brothers been together now for 21 vintages – to me it still seems like yesterday that I “discovered” their 1988s – but they point out that most of their present crew has been together for nearly a decade, which is bound to have been instrumental in their having been able to repeatedly expand into new vineyards without sacrificing the highest standards, not to mention with their enthusiasm still youthful.Importer: Weygandt-Metzler, Unionville, PA; tel. (610) 486-0800